View the (PDF Format) of this document
Foreword
List of Acronyms
2.1 The Transport Industry in the SADC Region
2.2 HIV / AIDS in the Transport Sector in South Africa
2.3 Roadside Health and Information Units
3.1 Policy Positions
3.2 The overall goal of the Transport Sector HIV/AIDS
3.3 Main objectives
3.4 General Principles for the Transport Sector
3.5 Areas of Strategic Focus
4.1 Policy Formulation and Development
4.2 Strategic Planning
4.3 Co-Ordination
4.4 Communication and Advocacy- Promotion of Best Practices
4.5 Monitoring & Evaluation Systems
5.1 Programme Components and Accountability
5.2 Strategic Plans
5.3 Monitoring & evaluation Framework 19 5.4 Reporting Cycle
List Generated by Stakeholders on best practices (27 July 2001)
The HIV-AIDS epidemic has impacted dramatically on all spheres of human life within the SADC region.
Its continuing spread is a cross-border issue of critical significance for the transport industry. We recognise that there are many competing demands on government and private sector social responsibility resources – but we see this as a challenge to our collective creativity. The National Department of Transport has therefore fully committed itself to the development of a coordinated cross-sectoral HIV-AIDS strategy that will mobilise every available public and private resource to combat the further spread of the epidemic through the veins and arteries of our transport system.
One of the most important elements of this strategy is that it unites government policy with best practice in the transport-related agencies and with a range of independent initiatives developed over the past few years in the various sectors of the transport industry. This document reflects the creativity of all the caring employers and employees in the transport sector who have worked hard to address the HIV-Aids epidemic in a meaningful way.
There can be no pause or let-up in the battle against HIV-AIDS. So, whilst recognising the value of what has been achieved so far, government and the industry have also recognised the need to lift their joint efforts to a higher level. This level can only be reached by incorporating HIV-Aids programmes into every aspect of our daily lives. Every truck driver, taxi driver, bus operator, commuter, passenger, pilot, air steward and seafarer can either be part of the problem or become part of the solution. We are in close touch with each other and we are a potential army of millions of HIV-Aids activists. If we do things right and act together we can reach into the heart of every home in this country. Our transport network offers us a potent weapon in this battle. It moves millions of people every day, both within and across our borders. These movements can either continue to widen the spread of HIV-Aids or become a powerful channel for disseminating the information, knowledge and understanding upon which effective prevention depends.
We urgently need to consolidate a partnership that delivers telling results. We are therefore appealing to every individual, organisation and government department with a stake in the transport sector to participate actively in the implementation of the strategy. We need to be visible in our involvement in Aids education, workplace awareness, outreach programmes, educational projects and sensitisation campaigns. We need to get better organised, raise the tempo of our actions and demonstrate our passion and commitment. I believe that this document can play an important part in helping us all to achieve the goals we have set ourselves.
| ACSA |
Airports Company of South Africa |
| ATNS |
Air Traffic Navigation Services of South Africa |
| CBRTA |
Cross Border Road Transport Agency |
| EU |
European Union |
| FESARTA |
Federation of Regional of Regional Road Transport Agency |
| GTZ |
German technical Department |
| ILO |
International Labour Organisation |
| MEC |
Ministerial executive committee |
| MTCT |
Mother To Child Transmission |
| NACOSA |
National AIDS Co-ordinating Committee |
| NDOT |
National Department Of Transport |
| NBC |
National Bargaining Council |
| NRA |
National Road Agency |
| PWA |
Person Living With Aids |
| RFA |
Road Freight Association |
| SACAA |
South African Civil Aviation Authority |
| SAMSA |
South African Maritime Safety Authority |
| SADC |
Southern African Development Community |
| SATAWU |
South African Transport and Allied Workers Union |
| SARCC |
South African Rail Commuter Corporation Ltd |
| SATCC |
Southern Africa Transport Co-ordinating Council |
| STD |
Sexually Transmitted Disease |
| TB |
Tuberculosis |
| TETA |
Transport, Education and Training Authority |
| UNAIDS |
Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS |
| USAID |
United States Agency for International Development |
| VTC |
Voluntary HIV Testing and Counselling |
The purpose of this document is to address HIV/AIDS in the Transport Sector through an integrated strategy.
This document constitutes the National Transport Sector Strategy developed by the National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee. The intention of the strategic position stated here is to ensure that comprehensive support is provided in the implementation of targeted HIV/AIDS interventions at sector level in South Africa and neighbouring countries.
The challenges being addressed by the transport sector in respect of HIV/AIDS in South Africa and the Southern African Development Community (SADC) are well documented and are part of the inputs for this strategic document. The National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee was established to drive a sector oriented strategy aimed at enhancing and consolidating effective interventions through partnerships in government, non-profit organisations and private enterprise.
Among the values guiding the development of the National Transport Sector HIV/Aids Strategy are the following:
Various sources and processes informed the development of the strategic plan. Of particular importance was the consultative process undertaken by the National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee, inputs from key provincial role players as well as the organising of the Road Show by the National Department of Transport. In this regard, stakeholder workshops were conducted, with materials being produced for incorporation into this strategic plan. Additional information was sourced from published literature as well as documented HIV/AIDS projects in the region.
In finalising this document, the National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee has endeavoured to achieve a balance between incorporating all stakeholder inputs while ensuring that the document remains simple and practical in both structure and content. Based on the foregoing, the document has been divided into the following sections:
As in most parts of the SADC, South Africa recognises HIV/AIDS as one of the most serious challenges since independence and new political dispensation. In South Africa, prevalence rates suggest that close to 25% of the people may be living with HIV/AIDS. This information comes from The National HIV survey of women attending antenatal clinics at the public health services. These figures confirm the continued need for making HIV/AIDS a regional and national priority. The figure below provides tabulated estimates of HIV prevalence in the country.

Adapted form HIV/AIDS & STD strategic Plan for South Africa 2000 – 2005
Available information suggests that women between the ages of 20 and 30 have the highest prevalence rates. The majority of the people hard hit by the epidemic are the young black and economically disadvantaged populations. As many as 4.2 million South Africans are estimated to be living with AIDS and 550,000 are believed to be infected every year. It is estimated that HIV will infect about 6 million South Africans and about 1 million children will be orphaned by 2005.
The epidemic is being amplified by high prevalence of STD’s, multiple sexual partners and limited usage of condoms. The predisposing factors remain largely being, socio economic factors, migrant labourers, mobile sector (Transport Industry) illiteracy stigma and discrimination.
The government of South Africa has responded to the challenges brought about by the epidemic, beginning with the establishment of the National AIDS Coordinating Committee of South Africa (NACOSA). The committee was tasked with developing a national strategy on HIV/AIDS. Other initiatives that followed the establishment of this committee include South African National STD & AIDS and other Provincial STD and AIDS Directorate.
However, the response to the epidemic has been affected by a number of constraints namely limited human and financial resources, delay in the creation of district structures, limited referral systems and networking to ensure sustained care, home based care and terminal care facilities, limited integration of STDs & HIV/AIDS with interventions for TB, lack of provincial policies, guidelines and management protocols, medical care, support and counselling and discrimination of people living with AIDS. However, currently the government has high levels of structure that address issues relevant to HIV/AIDS. These structures include: Parliamentary Portfolio Committees on Health, Departments of Health, Welfare, Education, Transport and Justice, Director Generals Forum, Inter-department Committee on Aids, Inter-Ministerial Committee on Aids, Inter-Provincial structures and MEC for Health and Provincial Departments. There is close liaison among these structures. These institutions have been able to draw the support of nongovernmental organisations and funding agencies (HIV/AIDS & STD Strategic Plan for South Africa 2000).
The participants to the Stakeholders Workshop on Prevention of HIV/AIDS in the Road Transport Sector in Southern Africa held on 31 August 2001 in Midrand indicated the following; acknowledgement of HIV/AIDS pandemic as a major threat to the social and economic development of South Africa, and committed themselves to strengthening HIV/AIDS prevention through condom promotion and distribution, peer education and contribute to national HIV/AIDS issues in the transport sector.
A long existing history of population migration in the Sub-Saharan Africa has characterised pattern of social relationships and economic activities. Such movement of people across borders at given time has meant that there has been a huge demand for transport facilities. Also the countries in Sub-Saharan Africa have maintained significant trade in the region thus further promoting inter-country migration. Most of the countries are landlocked and this situation has ensured that road and rail transportation is an invaluable means of transporting both people and goods for trading. In addition air-travel in the region has become of significant convenience for business and holiday making. The World Bank (2000) notes that about 9.7 million people used air-travel and 830771 (ton –km million) goods were transported by rail in 1997. Everyday new relationships in social and business circles are created across borders of the region. As the world becomes increasingly globalised there are indications that populations will be more integrated than ever.
South Africa is part of this big picture. People in the SADC region have been coming to South Africa to work in the mines, the transport industry and various sectors of the economy for over a century. Some of these migrant workers settled in South Africa as they established families. Others returned to their countries of origin but not without establishing some form of social relationships with the local people. This pattern of social relationships continues to exist, and it has become less complex due to availability of transport and the well-developed road, rail and air travel systems. Within South Africa there have been huge population movements in the past fifty years or so. Most of the movements have been male dominated, as the transport and mining industries have favoured employment of men. These men have been moving between their families and places of employment with much ease and efficiency. Also South Africa has added dimension to the transport industry with a coastline. Sailors from all over the world have used South African ports for many years. Travel has always been accommodative of new experiences, including diseases. This transport networking in the SADC region is a fertile ground for the spread of HIV/AIDS.
Studies have indicated that basic understanding of the biomedical facts is of limited value to truck drivers (Matthew 2000). The study by the Medical Research Council of South Africa reports that at one stop, 95% of the drivers involved in the survey were infected with HIV. Of the 34% who indicated that they had stopped for sex while on their routes, there was a high percentage of condom non-users (29%) (MRCSA 2000). Accounts of truck drivers not wanting to know the result of the voluntary testing were well documented (November 2000). Other studies have sited poor work conditions and long absence from their families as contributory factors in having sexual encounters outside their relationships. These findings lead to recommendations about policy reform, peer education, normative changes in the trucking community (Wilson, Sibanda, Nyathi, Lamson, and Sibanda 1991). Other behavioural surveillance research indicates the need to promote peer and other educational strategies, including condom use and health seeking behaviours for STDs. This needs to be supported by improved access to, and quality of, selected health facilities at the truck stops (US AID Impact Project 2000).
South African Civil Aviation Authority has identified the need for HIV/AIDS interventions. The Authority’s medical services department hosted a workshop on HIV/AIDS in November 2000, which was attended by the aviation industry, medical services, the legal profession and the national and provincial departments of transport. A task group was formed to deal with legislation of testing for aviation personnel and to formulate an acceptable policy for the Aviation industry. The Authority promulgated a policy position that protects people living with HIV/Aids from discrimination, promote access to information and commits the industry to create a caring and supportive environment for employees living with HIV/Aids. The policy promotes confidentiality and recognises the rights and obligations of the industry’s employees (South African Civil Aviation 2001).
While rail travel, public and private transport operate effectively within South Africa and the SADC region, very little information documentation is available. This situation applies to the maritime industry as well. However evidence suggests that these forms of transportation contribute significantly to social relationships network and the pattern of the epidemic in the SADC region
Groupings of Transport Sector Stakeholders
The Roadside Health and Information Unit project is a product of the National Bargain Council for the Road Freight Industry. It is managed by the Learning Clinic (Pty) Ltd. Its main objective is to reduce transmission of HIV/AIDS by long distance truck drivers and commercial sex workers. The project has three levels of intervention namely the treatment of STDs for truck drivers, treatment of STDs for commercial sex workers and condom distribution for both truck drivers and commercial sex workers. STD treatments are supported by continued health education. A qualitative e research evaluation into the projects in Harrismith and Beautfort West suggests that there is a potentially good intervention even though interviewees highlight areas for improvement (McKay, Sarakinsiky, Morr, Sekgobela, Mokotong, Mokotong and Sham 2001). These Roadside Health Information Units provide useful lessons for use in the broad intervention projects within the Transport Sector in South Africa.
The SADC is committed to strengthening the response to HIV/AIDS epidemic in the member states. The SADC Health Ministers have shared visions and goals to reduce the impact of HIV through a multi-sector driven strategy.
The national government of South Africa endorses the policy position taken by SADC Member states and is a major participant in the deliberation of the SADC strategic framework. The National government supports initiatives that address the reduction of HIV transmission, support and care and research activities in all sector of the economy. The national government also recognises the role that the transport sector is playing in the economies of South Africa and the SADC region as a whole.
The provincial and local government structures articulate the need to address the impact of the epidemic in all spheres of life and are regarded as important structures to ensure the coordination and support of the national strategy on HIV/AIDS and STD’s
In countries such as Botswana, Lesotho, Swaziland and Tanzania HIV/AIDS policies recognise HIV/AIDS as a national disaster. Botswana and Tanzania regard the epidemic as a national crisis. Lesotho has declared the epidemic a national disaster that requires national prioritisation. Mozambique has a Strategic Plan that views the epidemic as having a huge negative impact on social and economic development of the country.
The Transport Sector family commits to establish and maintain a healthy community and a stable and comparative transportation sector by effectively preventing and managing HIV/AIDS.
3.3 Main Objectives
The Priority areas as adapted for the transport sector from the HIV/AIDS & STD Strategic Plan for South Africa are as follows:
Priority Area 1: Prevention
Priority Area 2: Treatment Care And Support
Priority Area 3: Research, Monitoring And Evaluation
Priority Area 4: Human And Legal Rights
Priority Area 5: Training and Development
3.4 General Principles for the Transport Sector
The following constitutes the guiding principles for the management of HIV/Aids Transport Sector
In order for the Transport Industry HIV/AIDS Strategic Plan to succeed there is a need to identify key areas that will drive the interventions forward. It must be noted that there exists complex relationships between the Transport Sector and certain key situations and conditions. Some of the conditions or situations that are pertinent to ensuring the success of the Strategic Plan include; the demographic situation, the socio economic situation, the psychosocial situation, the political situation, the socio-cultural situation, the gendered situation, the institutional development situation and the capacity building situation.
Demographics
There is need to understand the demography of the transport sector in order to create well-targeted programmes. It is necessary to investigate the size, location, age, sex, race, education, income and the extent of the family composition. These are crucial factors that enable one to make an informed decision about the members of the transport sector.
Gender Issues
The gender composition of the transport sector is related to the demography issues. However, there is slightly different dimension to it in that the sector is predominated by men. The relationship dynamics are tilted against the other gender in that men in this work environment are seen as financially resourceful. Therefore men are likely to influence the pattern of sexual relationship with their stable partners, wives and commercial sex workers.
Socio-Economic Environment
The socio-economic environment determines a number of things, viz the ability to resist sexual demands, choice of a partner and the number of partners one can afford, can determine patterns of social relationships. A sex partner who is financially dependent is disadvantaged when negotiating sex.
Psychosocial Climate
There is a need to understand how psychosocial issues translate into social phenomenon. For example a commercial sex worker who has low self-esteem is less likely to negotiate for safe sex. A driver who is under the influence of alcohol may find himself having unprotected sexual intercourse.
The Socio-Cultural Environment
The socio-cultural factors are involved in the shaping of people’s belief systems, values, perceptions, preferences and behaviours. Values may be against use of condoms in sexual relationships. Certain backgrounds permit multiple sexual relationships. Some of these factors are difficult to change but it is important to work with them in forms of achieving desired results. The factors have an important role in influencing sexual behaviour and attitudes towards sex and HIV/AIDS.
Political Environment
A conducive political environment is a prerequisite to successful programming. Appropriate policies, guidelines and legislation need to be encouraged, developed and received to meet the demands of HIV/AIDS issues. The political environment can affect work with commercial sex workers, participation of transport workers, condom marketing, access to health services and empowerment of women in relationships.
Institutional Development
Organisations involved in HIV/AIDS need to have operational and organisational capacity to sustain meaningful interventions. Such capacity could be developed through human resource development, management development, management information systems and other report requirements and ability to engage in institutional networking. While programmes on HIV/AIDS may be in place, absence of a well-developed institution sets such programmes for inefficiency, non-effectiveness or even collapse.
Capacity Building
The transport sector and related institutions are required to develop capacity to ensure sustainability. Such capacity development must ensure that individuals, families and the transport sector community receive appropriate support. Such support could be in the form of funding of projects, skills development for individuals and key family members and develop skills for fundraising for HIV/AIDS programmes for the transport sector community.
The Strategy baseline put forward here are based on the understanding that the sector strategy focuses on cross-cutting issues rather than operational projects. Based on this understanding, the programme areas identified include the following:
Representatives from the provincial governments and the eight sub sectors of the transport sector will be responsible for assisting in policy formulation, policy alignment, policy development and review. Their role will be focussing on macro policy issues through policy workshops, external local and international expertise. They will be in a position to review institutional frameworks, procedures and methods of programme development and implementation. The provincial government representatives will ensure that there is an appropriate reporting requirement and relationships will relevant government structures. The sub sector representatives will ensure that they work from an informed basis as far as information and decision processes are concerned with regard to their respective sub sectors.
The strategic planning is seen to be the responsibility of the representatives from the eight sub sectors in the transport sector in South Africa. The representatives will develop strategies based on the previous experience in HIV/AIDS prevention and support within South Africa, the SADC region and international projects. The focus would be on identifying sub sector priorities and developing relevant strategies to meet the needs of each sector. The transport sector will rely on the proven ability of the private voluntary organisation and non-governmental organisation in developing such strategies. In addition, the sector will use the feedback that is received from various provincial and district structures to draw appropriate strategies.
The National Transport HIV/AIDS Coordinating Committee will be overall responsible for the coordination and monitoring of programmes. To ensure the success of the committee it is expected that each organisation will identify and appoint a special projects officer to manage the coordination within their organisation. Provincial structures have been designated coordination points for each sub sector where reasonable links have been established. Each provincial government have appointed a coordinator. Among other activities the provincial coordinator will maintain and establish provincial working groups as part of creating well coordinated programme of action. The coordination will oversee operational plans, budget cycles, programmatic and financial reporting. In addition to this the coordination will be responsible for ensuring that formative assessment and baseline research, monitoring and evaluation, management information systems, programme development, human resources development and appropriate intervention models within the sub sectors are in place. The coordination will ensure that capacity building and institutional development are done. Capacity building may involve skills development in the areas of programming and fundraising.
Communication will be developed among sector partners such as National Department of Transport, Cross Boarder Road Transport Association, Taxi Associations and Non Governmental Organisations. Such communication will ensure that the is continued networking and collaboration for purposes of mobilising resources, brainstorming on programming issues, stakeholders identifying their needs and assets as part of developing and implementing, their projects. It is expected that advocacy for the transport sector and beneficiaries will be promoted by the national and provincial governments as well as other NGOs working in collaboration with the transport sector. (See Annexure A for comprehensive list)
In order for one to have an idea of success or failure in a project, monitoring and evaluation systems may need to be put in place in an organisation. Currently, most organisations involved in AIDS interventions do not have a systematic way of monitoring the process and outcomes of their interventions. The monitoring is either based on personal communication, non-systematic observation and workshops.
Appropriate methods of monitoring and evaluation need to be selected, determined on the basis of the character of the interventions. A common set of points has been identified in projects that have conducted monitoring and evaluation from time to time. The common issues for monitoring are:
The common issues for evaluation are:
- Direct field observation
- Participant observation
- Formal interviews
- Informal interview
- Conversation with key informants
- Focus group discussions
- Survey questionnaires
The National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee will undertake a process to determine a comprehensive programme to implement the interventions aimed at achieving the goal and objectives stated in section 3 above.
Based on the programme areas in section it is anticipated that the following will constitute the programme components and the framework of accountability:
Table 1. Expected Functions
|
PROGRAMME COMPONENT / STRUCTURE |
ROLE & RESPONSIBILITY |
|
Minister of Transport |
Overall Implementation of Strategy Plan |
|
National Co-ordinating Committee |
Policy Formulation and |
|
Provincial Co-ordinating Committee |
Alignment of Operational Policies |
|
Local Co-ordinating Committee |
Project Planning and Implementation |
|
National Department of Health |
National AIDS Policy Framework |
|
National Department of Transport |
National AIDS Policy Framework for Transport Sector |
|
Provincial Department of Transport |
Operational Policy Positions |
|
Transport Sub-Sector Partners |
Sub-Sector Support Programmes |
|
Non-Government Organisation |
Project Implementation |
|
Private Enterprise |
Work Place HIV/AIDS Policies |
5.2. Strategic Plans
In line with the National AIDS Plan processes, the transport sector will put in place multi-year and annual plans. Of particular importance will be the following plans:
The National Co-ordinating Committee will determine the specific contents of the plans.
Table 2. Summary of the Programme Components for Strategic HIV/AIDS Plan
|
Objective |
Recommended Activities |
|
Prevention |
Education and training programmes |
|
Treatment and care |
Implement Employee assistance programmes |
|
Research Monitoring, and evaluation |
Undertake continuous research |
|
Human and Legal Rights |
Develop policies using DOL as legal framework |
|
Training and Development |
Providing training on management of Aids |
5.3 Monitoring And Evaluation Framework
The monitoring and evaluation will have the following elements:
5.4 Reporting Cycle
Reporting will be done by the National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee : -Monthly Reports
Table 3. Summary of the Plan of Action for the Transport Sector Strategic AIDS Plan
|
Objective |
Activity |
Responsible Office |
Target audience |
Time frame |
Cost (R) |
|
1.Overall Implementation of the Plan of Action |
Delegation of Planning Implementing and monitoring |
Minister of Transport |
Transport Stakeholders |
30 November 2001-ongoing |
|
|
2.Status review |
Series meetings 1.Review of available documentation. 2.Review of project progress 3.Review of project needs and resources. 4.Documentation of proceedings. |
Provincial, local government and sub sector representatives. |
Government officials and sector representatives. |
15 January to 25 January 2002. |
Contributions by Sector Partners in the National HIV/AIDS Transport Co-ordinating Committee |
|
3.Policy formulation, alignment and development |
Workshops 1.Policy review of documentation. 2.Policy formulation. 3.Plolicy alignment. 4.Documentation. |
Provincial, local government and sub sector representatives. |
Government officials, non-governmental organisations, funding organisations and sector representatives. |
28 January to 30 January 2002 |
|
|
3.Strategic planning |
Series meetings 1.Identify project needs. 2.Making projects 3.Operational plans. 4.Budget. 5.Setting timeline 6.Procedure compliances. |
Provincial government and sub sector representatives |
Provincial governments Sub-sectors |
15 January to 25 February 2002 |
|
|
4.Coordination |
1.Resources. 2.Tasks. 3.Communication 4.Meetings and workshops. |
Provincial government representatives. |
Government officials, funding organisations and sub sector representatives. |
Ongoing |
|
|
5.Communication and advocacy |
1.Policy issues. 2.Research findings. 3.Gender issues. 4.Work conditions. 5.Care and support. 6.Capacity building. |
Provincial government, funding organisations, sector and non-governmental organisations representatives. |
NDOT, employers, personnel, families, the community and government departments |
Ongoing |
|
|
6.Research, monitoring and evaluation |
1. Monitoring and evaluation framework 2.Formative assessment and baseline research. 3.Process evaluation. 3.Impact evaluation. |
National Coordinating Committee Provincial government and sub sector representatives , academic institutions and funding organisations. |
Stakeholders Pilots, drivers, commercial sex workers, commuters and Taxis. |
1.Ongoing 2.Project inception. 3.Midterm of project. 4.End of project. |
The Transport Sector HIV/AIDS Strategic Plan is a guidance document .To give effect to the contents of this document all Transport Sector Stakeholders will have to commit themselves to participating in the implementation programme. In the words of the Minister of Transport ," we are a mighty army of activist against Aids", and we do care.
A Word of Thanks
The process to create one strategy for the whole Transport Sector started in April 2001, under the auspices of the National Department of Transport’s HIV/Aids Committee. The buy in from the members of the National Transport Coordinating Committee however, provided the success behind the strategy document. Thank You, to all who made this document happen.
|
|
||||
|
|||||
A LIST GENERATED BY STAKEHOLDERS ON BEST PRACTICES (27 July 2001)
Categories and Types of Best Practises
The following categories and types of best practises that need to be considered and developed were identified:
Management practises
Marketing practises
Medical practises
The following ideas for marketing and promoting best practises were identified:
Management of Best Practises Resources
The following ideas for managing best practises resources were identified:
The following ideas for training and development of best practises were identified:
The following ideas for principles regarding best practises were identified:
The following ideas for best practises for stakeholder involvement were identified:
The following ideas for best practises for ongoing review and report-back were identified: